High Cost of Buying a Home Could Make Multifamily Investments Attractive

TLDR: Rising home prices and higher mortgage rates have upended the traditional American path to homeownership, pushing more people to rent long-term. With median home prices soaring and financing costs eating up a larger share of incomes, the affordability gap has widened dramatically. This shift has made renting not just a temporary phase but a preferred lifestyle for many, especially millennials and Gen Z. At the same time, multifamily properties have emerged as an attractive investment due to their diversified income streams, cost efficiencies, and resilience during economic downturns. These assets are further buoyed by robust demographic trends and strong regional rental demand, offering significant long-term growth potential.

For decades, the traditional American dream followed a well-worn path: young adults would rent an apartment—often sharing with friends during college or early career years—and eventually save enough for a down payment on an entry-level home, usually just after marriage. However, recent shifts in the housing market, marked by soaring prices and rising mortgage rates, have fundamentally disrupted this model. With the gap between owning and renting at its widest in 15 years, renting is increasingly becoming the preferred choice for many, while multifamily properties have emerged as an attractive investment alternative. Let’s sink our teeth into the economic forces, demographic trends, and operational advantages that make multifamily real estate a compelling long-term investment in today’s evolving market.

The Changing Housing Market

The Traditional Path vs. Today’s Reality

Historically, the journey from renting to homeownership was almost a rite of passage. College graduates entered the rental market with the clear goal of eventually owning a home—a goal often achieved through years of disciplined savings, career progression, and, eventually, marriage. This narrative was underpinned by the relative affordability of entry-level homes and favorable mortgage conditions. Yet, over the past several years, several key factors have radically altered this landscape:

• Skyrocketing Home Prices: From January 2020 to August 2023, the median U.S. home price surged approximately 38%, reaching around $550,000. This rapid increase has placed homeownership out of reach for many would-be buyers.
  
• Rising Mortgage Rates: With the average rate on a 30-year fixed mortgage climbing to around 7.55%, monthly mortgage payments have become significantly higher. For example, using a 20% down payment on a median-priced home today might result in a mortgage payment that consumes nearly 29% of a typical U.S. family’s monthly income.
  
• Declining Buyer Demand: The combination of high prices and expensive financing has led to a steep decline in mortgage applications, hitting a 28-year low, while existing home sales have similarly retreated. This trend indicates that many potential buyers are either delaying their home purchases or turning to alternative living arrangements.
  

These factors have not only disrupted the traditional pathway to homeownership but have also contributed to a widening affordability gap that makes renting an increasingly attractive option.

The Growing Appeal of Renting

The shift in economic realities has pushed many potential homeowners toward the rental market. A recent study from Redfin highlighted that in most U.S. markets, the cost of owning a home is approximately 25% more per month than renting—except in select cities such as Detroit, Cleveland, Houston, and Philadelphia. This premium on homeownership has led to a significant transformation in housing preferences.

While renting was once seen merely as a transitional phase, it is now emerging as a long-term solution for many. With the monthly financial burden of owning a home rising, many families and individuals have opted to embrace renting as a lifestyle choice rather than a temporary setback. This trend has spurred a surge in demand for rental properties, particularly in urban areas where job opportunities and amenities are concentrated.

Economic Forces and Demographic Trends

Economic Pressures on Homebuyers

The current economic environment has placed tremendous pressure on potential homebuyers. The interplay of several factors has made the dream of homeownership increasingly elusive:

1. Escalating Home Prices: The rapid rise in home prices over the past few years has been driven by a combination of limited inventory, high demand, and increased construction costs. This price surge has outpaced wage growth, making it difficult for many families to accumulate sufficient savings for a down payment.
   
2. Increased Mortgage Costs: The upward trend in mortgage rates has compounded affordability challenges. A higher rate not only increases monthly payments but also extends the total amount paid over the life of the loan. For instance, the jump from rates near 3-4% in previous years to the current levels significantly alters the financial feasibility of buying a home.
   
3. Income versus Cost: With the U.S. national median income at about $96,300 and the median price of an existing home around $407,100, the financial burden becomes starkly evident when factoring in a 20% down payment and high monthly payments. This imbalance has contributed to a notable decline in homebuyer participation in the market.
   

The result is a cooling of the homebuying market, with mortgage applications at their lowest in decades, pushing more individuals to consider renting as a viable and even preferable alternative.

Demographic Shifts Favoring Rentals

Beyond raw economics, several demographic trends are reshaping housing preferences:

• Millennials and Generation Z: These generations are increasingly entering the workforce burdened by student debt and facing a competitive job market. Their lifestyle preferences lean toward flexibility and urban living, making renting more appealing than the long-term commitment of homeownership.
  
• Changing Household Composition: Modern households are diverse, with an increasing number of single-parent families, individuals choosing to live alone, and a generally aging population. Each of these factors contributes to a sustained demand for rental units, as these demographic groups often prioritize location, amenities, and flexibility over the responsibilities of owning a home.
  
• Immigration Patterns: Immigration has historically bolstered demand for rental housing in many metropolitan areas. Although immigration levels dipped during the pandemic, any rebound in immigration can further stimulate demand for multifamily housing.
  

Regional demand is also undergoing significant shifts. States such as Texas, Florida, and California are projected to account for 40% of future rental demand, with estimates suggesting that these regions alone will require the construction of approximately 1.5 million new apartments by 2035. This demographic momentum is a key driver behind the rising appeal of multifamily investments.

Multifamily Properties: A Compelling Investment Opportunity

The Financial and Operational Benefits

Investing in multifamily properties offers several advantages, particularly in an environment where renting has become the norm:

• Diversified Income Stream: One of the primary benefits of multifamily investments is the consistent and diversified cash flow. Unlike single-family rentals, which rely on one tenant, multifamily properties generate income from multiple units. This diversification mitigates the risk of vacancy and provides a steady revenue stream even if one or two units are temporarily unoccupied.
  
• Economies of Scale: Multifamily properties enable investors to take advantage of operational efficiencies. By managing several units within one property, costs related to maintenance, management, and renovations are spread across many tenants, reducing the per-unit expense. This centralized approach can significantly boost overall profitability.
  
• Inflation Hedge: As inflation drives up the cost of living, multifamily investments offer a natural hedge. Rental rates can be adjusted periodically to reflect increases in operating costs, helping investors maintain the real value of their income over time.
  
• Resilience in Economic Downturns: Historically, the multifamily sector has shown remarkable resilience during economic recessions. Data from the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) of 2008-2009 indicate that multifamily properties experienced much smaller increases in vacancy rates and lower rental losses compared to other real estate asset classes. This resilience is due in part to the essential nature of housing—people will always need a place to live, even in tough economic times.

Market Fundamentals Supporting Multifamily Investments

Recent market data further underscores the strength of the multifamily sector:

• Positive Net Absorption Trends: In the second quarter of 2023, the U.S. multifamily market recorded a net absorption of 70,200 units—the first substantial quarterly demand since the first quarter of 2021. This indicates that, despite some upward pressure on vacancy rates (which increased slightly to 5%, aligning with long-term averages), demand for rental units remains robust.
  
• Investor Confidence: Even though multifamily investments saw a dip in transaction volumes—with investments at $27.5 billion in the second quarter compared to roughly $96 billion a year earlier—the asset class still commanded the largest share (35%) of commercial real estate investment. A CBRE study even found that multifamily properties have become the top investment choice for 30% of global investors, a significant milestone in the sector’s history.
  
• Supply Shortages: A study by the National Multifamily Housing Council (NMHC) and the National Apartment Association highlighted a shortage of 600,000 apartment units in 2021 alone. This shortfall is partly attributed to underbuilding since the 2008 financial crisis and is expected to continue, with projections suggesting the U.S. will need to construct 4.3 million new apartments by 2035. This supply-demand imbalance is likely to support rental rates and property values over the long term.

Strategies for Investing in Multifamily Properties

Market Fundamentals Supporting Multifamily Investments

For investors looking to capitalize on these trends, a well-planned strategy is essential. Here are several key strategies to consider:

Evaluating Local Market Conditions

1. Identify High-Demand Regions: Focus on areas with robust job markets, growing populations, and limited housing supply. Urban centers and economically dynamic regions often present the best opportunities for multifamily investments.
   
2. Analyze Vacancy Rates and Rent Growth: Look for markets where vacancy rates remain low and rental growth is strong. Historical data and current trends can help determine whether a particular market is ripe for investment.
   
3. Consider Demographic Trends: Areas with a high concentration of millennials, Gen Z, and immigrants, as well as regions experiencing significant population growth, are likely to see sustained demand for rental housing.

Financing and Economic Considerations

1. Monitor Mortgage Rates: While current mortgage rates have increased the cost of homeownership, any future decline could narrow the affordability gap and further boost multifamily demand. Investors should stay abreast of economic forecasts and rate trends.
   
2. Evaluate Debt and Equity Structures: With the operational efficiencies inherent in multifamily properties, investors have a variety of financing options available—from traditional bank loans to private equity. Structuring the investment appropriately can maximize returns and mitigate risk.
   
3. Plan for Long-Term Economic Shifts: Given the cyclical nature of real estate, a long-term investment horizon is key. Investors should be prepared for economic fluctuations and position their portfolios to capitalize on the inherent stability of the multifamily sector.

Operational Efficiency and Asset Management

1. Centralized Property Management: Efficient management is a critical component of multifamily success. Implementing centralized systems for rent collection, maintenance, and tenant communications can streamline operations and reduce costs.
   
2. Capital Improvements: Regular upgrades and maintenance not only improve tenant satisfaction but also enhance the property’s value over time. Strategic capital improvements can lead to higher rents and better occupancy rates.
   
3. Technology Integration: Embracing property technology solutions—such as smart home systems and online management platforms—can further improve operational efficiencies, enhance the tenant experience, and boost overall profitability.

Strategies for Investing in Multifamily Properties

Despite the current challenges in the housing market, the long-term outlook for multifamily investments remains positive. Multifamily properties are well-positioned to benefit from enduring demographic trends, such as the shift towards urban living, increasing single-person households, and sustained rental demand among younger generations. Moreover, even in the face of economic volatility, multifamily assets have demonstrated a capacity to maintain stable income streams and deliver consistent returns.

Analysts point out that while market conditions may fluctuate, the underlying fundamentals—such as the essential need for housing and the persistent imbalance between supply and demand—will continue to support rental rates and property values. This resilience makes multifamily real estate not only a defensive play during economic downturns but also an attractive growth opportunity over the long term.

Investors with a forward-looking perspective recognize that the traditional barriers to homeownership are shifting. As homeownership becomes less accessible due to higher prices and stricter lending conditions, the rental market is likely to expand further. In this context, multifamily properties offer a way to capture the economic benefits of a growing rental sector, while also providing operational advantages that can enhance overall returns.

Multifamily Investing Makes Sense

The American housing landscape is undergoing a dramatic transformation. With homeownership increasingly out of reach for many—due to soaring prices, rising mortgage rates, and a pronounced affordability gap—renting has evolved from a temporary measure to a long-term housing strategy. For investors, this shift represents a significant opportunity. Multifamily properties, with their consistent cash flow, operational efficiencies, inflation-hedging capabilities, and resilience during economic downturns, have emerged as a standout investment choice in this evolving market.

As demographic trends such as urban migration, an aging population, and the rising prominence of millennials and Gen Z reshape the rental market, the demand for multifamily housing is expected to grow even further. Strategic investors who understand these dynamics can position themselves to benefit from the long-term stability and growth potential inherent in multifamily assets.

Whether you’re a seasoned real estate investor or new to the market, embracing the multifamily investment opportunity means more than simply adjusting to a changing market—it means capitalizing on a powerful trend that is redefining the way Americans live and invest in real estate. By carefully evaluating market conditions, leveraging operational efficiencies, and maintaining a long-term investment perspective, multifamily properties offer a compelling risk/reward profile that is well-suited to today’s dynamic economic environment.

In the end, as traditional homeownership becomes an increasingly challenging goal, multifamily real estate stands out as a beacon of stability and potential. It is not just an investment in property, but an investment in a future where resilient, income-producing assets can provide both security and growth, even in the midst of market uncertainty.

Let’s Connect

Would you like to discuss this article with one of our Wealth Development Representatives? Fill out the form below to be connected.

About CaliberCos Inc. 

With more than $2.9 billion of managed assets, including estimated costs to complete assets under development, Caliber’s 16-year track record of managing and developing real estate is built on a singular goal: make money in all market conditions. Our growth is fueled by our performance and our competitive advantage: we invest in projects, strategies, and geographies that global real estate institutions do not. Integral to our competitive advantage is our in-house shared services group, which offers Caliber greater control over our real estate and visibility to future investment opportunities. There are multiple ways to participate in Caliber’s success: invest in Nasdaq-listed CaliberCos Inc. and/or invest directly in our Private Funds.

Investor Considerations

The information contained herein is general in nature and is not intended, and should not be construed, as accounting, financial, investment, legal, or tax advice, or opinion, in each instance provided by Caliber or any of its affiliates, agents, or representatives. The reader is cautioned that this material may not be applicable to, or suitable for, the reader’s specific circumstances, desires, needs, and requires consideration of all applicable facts and circumstances. The reader understands and acknowledges that, prior to taking any action relating to this material, the reader (i) has been encouraged to rely upon the advice of the reader’s accounting, financial, investment, legal, and tax advisers with respect to the accounting, financial, investment, legal, tax, and other considerations relating to this material, (ii) is not relying upon Caliber or any of its affiliates, agents, employees, managers, members, or representatives for accounting, financial, investment, legal, tax, or business advice, and (iii) has sought independent accounting, financial, investment, legal, tax, and business advice relating to this material. Caliber, and each of its affiliates, agents, employees, managers, members, and representatives assumes no obligation to inform the reader of any change in the law or other factors that could affect the information contained herein.

Sign Up For Our Newsletter!

Stay up to date on Caliber fund updates and more.